Human sclera tissue is mainly collagen; therefore, it is not easily usable for immunohistochemistry. To achieve the goal of performing immunohistochemistry for confocal microscopy of scleral tissue, a laminating technique was used.
The sclera is a dense connective tissue that covers and protects the eye. It mainly consists of dense collagen bundles (types I, III, IV, V, VI, and VII). Due to its autofluorescence, opaqueness, and thickness, it has not been found suitable for confocal microscopy. An alternative approach to the one presented here, which uses formalin-fixed sclera embedded in paraffin for immunohistochemistry, has technical challenges, especially when preheating the tissue for antigen retrieval. Since the sclera is relatively poor in both cells and vessels, the use of larger tissue samples was explored to help prevent overlooking cells and to understand their localization in relation to vessels and other anatomical sites. To allow for the analysis of larger tissue samples under the confocal microscope, a laminating technique was performed to create thin layers from the sclera. Following the analysis of results of CD31 blood vessels and lymphatic vessel endothelial hyaluronan receptor 1 (LYVE1) positive cells, for which approval for scientific examination was obtained, the advantages and limitations of this method are discussed.
The sclera is the rigid outer layer that covers the eye, which is made of dense connective tissue. It helps to protect intraocular structures and to maintain intraocular pressure. Thus, the sclera is essential for clear vision. It is devoid of lymphatic vessels 1,2 and thereby forms an outer lymphatic-free border between it and the lymphatic-free inner eye 3-7. It also provides attachment sites for extraocular muscles, thereby sharing anatomical similarities with tendons. Because the sclera mainly consists of dense bundles of type I collagen and has smaller numbers of collagen types III, IV, V, VI, VIII 8,9 and elastin 10,11, this tissue is not easy to use for immunohistochemistry.
Anatomically, the sclera can be separated into three main layers: (1) the superficial vascularized episclera, found underneath the conjunctiva and tenon's capsule and towards the sides and the back of the eye facing the orbit; (2) the scleral stroma, the main part of the sclera; and (3) the lamina fusca, which is a thin, pigmented layer located directly above the uvea. Our anatomical knowledge about the sclera stems mainly from the first half of the 20th century. At that time, researchers studied the anatomy of vasculature mainly by using India ink injections 12 and vascular casting 13-15. Later, it was researched in angiographic studies 16-19.
Since that time, older techniques have been improved and new ones have been developed that have allowed us to supplement previous anatomical knowledge. For example, it has only been about one decade since we have had such reliable lymphatic markers as lymphatic vascular endothelium specific hyaluronan receptor-1 (LYVE1) 20 or podoplanin 21. Confocal microscopy offers new possibilities for studying the anatomical features of the different tissues of the eye. It allows for multiple stains to be used for differentiating markers of cells or for the localization of cells in relation to blood vessels and other anatomical structures. It provides an overview when the sample is of a larger size and allows us to scan through a sample when in search of a specific cell type. With Z-Stack technology, confocal microscopy can be used for samples up to 100-200 µm. The sclera differs in thickness between 0.3 mm behind the muscle insertions and 1 mm at the posterior pole 11. Due to both its thickness and opaqueness, the sclera is not suitable for confocal microscopy using traditional methods.
To remedy this, scleral tissues were laminated to allow for their analysis with confocal microscopy. This technology is useful for gaining a better understanding of both physiological and pathological situations in the human sclera.
The use of human tissues must be reviewed and approved by an institutional review board or the equivalent. The work described here was approved by the local ethics committee and had approval for scientific examination. This work was performed according to the Declaration of Helsinki. The human scleral specimens were obtained from the eyes of globe donors (maximum post-mortem time 24 hr) at the Eye Bank of the Department of Ophthalmology, University of Cologne, Germany.
1. Experimental Preparation
2. Prepare the Sclera
3. Perform Immunohistochemistry
In the representative experiments performed here, there are demonstrable benefits derived from the use of this particular laminating technique. The first experiment illustrates the diverse network of the episcleral blood vessel plexus in three representative pictures (Figure 3). The vessels are positive for CD31.
The second experiment shows immune cells, in particular LYVE1 + cells of the episclera and their relationship to the CD31 positive blood vessels. Here Z-Stack technology was used at 10X magnification to scan through the tissue and understand three-dimensional relations of blood vessels and immune cells (Figure 4).
The sclera, as well as the enclosed extraocular muscles, can be analyzed for the presence of blood vessels or immune cells. Figure 5 shows LYVE1 positive cells and CD31 positive blood vessels.
Figure 1: Schematic Picture of the Human Eye. Here is a schematic of the cross-section of the human eye. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 2: Schematic Picture of the Laminating Technique. The sclera is carefully held with colibri forceps and laminated into fine layers using a scalpel. Repeating this step leads to thin tissue slides that can be used for confocal microscopy. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 3: Episcleral Blood Vessel Plexus, Immunopositive for CD31. A and B are derived from the anterior episclera, while C is from the posterior location. Scale bar indicates 100 µm. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 4: CD31 + Blood vessels and LYVE1 + Cells in a z-stack, Showing the Anatomical Relations Between Them. Small vessels and larger ones may overlap. Scale bar indicates 100 µm. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 5: Enclosed in the Sclera are the Extraocular Muscles. They contain a similar fine blood vessel network and some LYVE1 + cells. Scale bar indicates 200 µm. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Laminating the human sclera is a method for performing confocal microscopy on this tissue. A critical step in this process is the use of ethanol instead of formalin for affixing the tissue. In our experience, better results are obtained when using ethanol instead of formalin for fixation. Blunt scalpels aggravate the procedure and should be avoided. Similarly, the drying up of the sclera should be avoided, as it complicates the procedure and reduces the quality of the images.
Regarding the immunohistochemical staining, other antibodies than the ones applied here can be used. In general, collagen shows more auto-fluorescence and background in the green channel, therefore red, blue, and far-red channels show better results with less background.
However, there are several limitations of the technique. Laminating the sclera requires a lot of practice, as it is a microsurgical procedure performed under a microscope. Because this technique is performed manually, the single laminated slices are not exactly the same size and differ in their thickness within one piece of tissue. To have tissues of exactly the same size, trepanation might be an alternative, although the thickness of the layers will still vary. To achieve an exactly defined thickness for the scleral sections, an automated microkeratome might be an alternative for future experiments. If lamination is performed with layers that are too thick, the cover slide may dislocate, and the tissue can potentially dry out. The exact borders between episclera and stroma may be hard to differentiate once the laminations are performed.
Despite this, laminating the sclera has several advantages in the use of immunohistochemistry, particularly when compared to formalin-fixed paraffin embedded immunohistochemistry, which is the standard method in the current clinical situation. Laminating the sclera allows confocal microscopy to be performed, larger sized areas of sclera to be analyzed, different layers of the sclera to be examined, as well as the screening and scanning of tissue. In contrast, when working with formalin-fixed paraffin embedded samples, the sclera changes its consistency in an unhelpful way during preheating for antigen retrieval. Throughout the heating process, the collagen fibers shrivel and the tissue loses contact with the slide. Previously, the vessel plexus in the episclera have only been visible by using angiographic techniques or in the whole mount view, but not in cross sections.
In addition to the technical difficulties, the sclera is relatively avascular and relatively poor in immune cells compared to other tissues in the eye, such as the retina. Therefore, when using formalin-fixed paraffin embedded slides, which are usually 4 µm thick, multiple slides are needed to detect positive cells in the sclera. Recently, it was shown using this laminating technique that the human sclera is not acellular, but contains plenty of LYVE1+ macrophages to accumulate around blood vessels 1.
To summarize, performing confocal microscopy on laminated scleral sections is a promising tool to investigate pathological disorders in the future, such as scleritis, uveitis, or trauma.
The authors have nothing to disclose.
German Research Foundation (FOR2240 “(Lymph) Angiogenesis and Cellular Immunity in Inflammatory Diseases of the Eye” to CC and LMH; HE 6743/2-1 and HE 7643/3-1 to LMH; CU47/6-1 to CC), German Cancer Aid (to LMH and CC), GEROK program University of Cologne (to SLS and LMH), and EU COST BM1302 “Joining Forces to Corneal Regeneration” (to CC).
96% ethanol | Merck Chemicals, Darmstadt, Germany | P075.4 | |
binocular stereo microscope | Motic, Hongkong, China | n.a | |
26G needles | Terumo, Leuven, Belgium | 303800 | |
15.5mm trepan | Geuder, Heidelberg, Germany | n.a | |
no.10 scalpel | Feather, pfm medical, Osaka, Japan | 2E+08 | |
ophthalmic scalpel micro feather | Feather, pfm medical, Osaka, Japan | no. 7657BR | |
CD 31 antibody (monoclonal mouse anti human) | Dako, USA | IR610 | |
LYVE1 antibody (polyclonal rabbit anti human) | Zytomed, Germany | RBK014-05 | |
goat anti mouse FITC antibody | Sigma Aldrich, Steinheim, Germany | F0257 | |
goat anti rabbit Cy3 antibody | Dianova, Germany | 111-165-003 | |
Goat Serum normal | Dako, Glostrup, Denmark | X090710-8 | |
DAPI | Carl Roth GmbH, Karlsruhe, Germany | 6335.1 | |
microscope slides | Engelbrecht, Edermünde, Germany | WC7695002 | |
Coverslips 24x24mm | Th. Gayer, Lohmar, Germany | 7695026 | |
DAKO fluorescent mounting medium | DAKO, USA | S3023 | |
LSM Meta 510 confocal microscopy | Carl Zeiss AG, Jena, Germany | n.a |